CarpForum.co.uk brand mark, a blue stylized fish with a white eye and a smooth modern look, set in the site header against a clean background CarpForum.co.uk wordmark in a bold flowing script style, reading CarpForum.co.uk, displayed in the site header
Menu
Utils
Go Premium Who's Online Members Weather Venues Photo Gallery Articles Events calendar
Account
Login Register
Favourite reel manufacturer (21 posts / 703 views)
Poll
Which is your favourite?
Okuma 5% · 4 votes
Sonik 0% · 0 votes
Fox 0% · 0 votes
Shimano 43% · 38 votes
Daiwa 44% · 39 votes
Penn 8% · 7 votes
Log in or register to vote. 88 members voted
Karlos Karlos
MODERATORMOD
Posts: 14,278
Post #1 7 Nov 2026 19:58
2
This is a test post/poll to check if polling works on live, but we can treat this as a bit of fun if you like.
I may have missed a manufacturer or two but like I say, just a test thread.

Polls are another Premium feature (to create a poll) but any member can vote on it
LA_ LA_
Posts: 928
Post #2 8 Nov 2026 00:02
1
Anything other than shimano is inferior 😁😎😐😜
Karlos Karlos
MODERATORMOD
Posts: 14,278
Post #3 8 Nov 2026 02:13
0
In reply to Post #2
I have almost always gone Shimano based on their reputation for gearing. Everybody I knew wanted Shimano gears on their mountain bikes etc
I have a set of the first ever Basias, used them for maybe a season, then bought some second hand Shimano big pits and the clutch on the Shimanos was so much better. I rarely dust off the (OLD) Basias now.

That said I have heard high praise of Daiwa in more recent years. I've had a little fondle with some at the shows and one or two of them do feel nice, so never say never πŸ˜‰

After reading on here about Penn being nice and smooth I considered getting a couple for my Pike setup
silverfish silverfish
Posts: 2,685
Post #4 8 Nov 2026 07:35
0
I haven't owned a lot of reels, Mitchell 300Ss to 6010s, sold up late 90s, started again and bought 6000GTEs., then blue Emblems Zs for a bigger water.
The 6000GTEs are 26 years old, used, abused and still working as they should,, only ever cleaned the line rollers. Two are on my barbel rods.
Bought a pair of SS2600s for my light rod fishing, somewhat disappointed with the huge 'retro' step backwards until I converted the caps to QD and fitted carbontex washers. Bought two more and still use them for everything.else.

Bought Ultegra 5500 XTBs 2009-ish...did everything they were supposed to but somehow fell short of expectations.
It was only a matter of months before I hated them..on the rods for a couple of years and they've been in the loft since.
Regreted selling the Zs straight away, I should have got shot of the XTBs ASAP and bought 5000Ts.
Not as if I couldn't of afforded them at the time.
But by then I'd reverted to 2.5 test rods and SS2600s .with a Z5000A on a 3.5 SP as distance back-up.

Was briefly tempted by some Technium 10000XTs at a very good price..in 2011πŸ˜‚..just didn't like the handles..still don't like Shimano handles
IF I was to tackle the clubs bigger water I'd dig out the XTBs but irrespective of advancements my heart would still be set on some 5000Ts.
Darkieallard
Posts: 4,943
Post #5 8 Nov 2026 08:01
0
Ive always thought the gearing is best in Shimano but the aesthetics of Diawa are harder wearing.
stuart666 stuart666
Posts: 4,798
Post #6 8 Nov 2026 08:51
0
Carp reels Daiwa. My spinning/lure reels shimano. My fav all time reel are abu suverans.
vossy1 vossy1
MODERATORMOD
Posts: 9,319
Post #7 8 Nov 2026 12:38
0
I've gone Daiwa simply on hours used but I'm equally happy with Shimano.
wandle1 wandle1
Posts: 7,541
Post #8 8 Nov 2026 15:45
0
I've got a soft spot for Mitchell's, especially the ottomatics, and 1958 boomerangs,anti reverse ..

I've had my Titanos xsa 4500 for a long time ,bought 2nd hand ,I oil the port now and then, and clean them regularly..

think my next set will be Penns ,poss the rivals 6000
NR4carper NR4carper
Posts: 42
Post #9 8 Nov 2026 20:22
0
I use basias I’m on my 2nd set now absolutely love them, I have had shims in the past but never the high end 1s so can’t compare, I did have a pair of esp reels on my 9ft quickdraws and for the money they were brilliant reels
maplecream
Posts: 725
Post #10 8 Nov 2026 20:58
0
Used shimanos since the early seaspin baitrunners, currently use the xta med baitrunners Ci4 for carp fishing.
Have recently retired my old 6000 gte baitrunners, used for spring tench fishing, and river piking, replaced with okuma pulzar 6000, vv impressed!
Jamesvg Jamesvg
Posts: 1,166
Post #11 8 Nov 2026 21:29
0
I favour Daiwa for carp and coarse however use Shimano exclusively for lure and spod/marker work.
I have no real reasoning behind this, the reels from each manufacturer just 'feel right' to me in those situations.
RKB
Posts: 1,782
Post #12 9 Nov 2026 07:45
0
LOL. Where have all the Okuma fan boys gone?
edski119 edski119
Posts: 100
Post #13 9 Nov 2026 13:45
0
In reply to Post #12
Still here, for the money i really don’t think Okumas can be beaten at the moment.
But Shimano then Daiwa are still king. Just have to have slightly deeper pockets.
Belch Belch
MODERATORMOD
Posts: 4,720
Post #14 9 Nov 2026 14:48
2
Daiwas are for fishing - Shimano is for cycling / spandex fetish wearing / shouting at other road users at the weekends
Canalcarper71 Canalcarper71
Posts: 1,419
Post #15 9 Nov 2026 14:49
0
Love my basia customs saved hard for them last me for years to come
Are you sure?

This action cannot be undone.

Yes, continue

Loading…