CarpForum.co.uk brand mark, a blue stylized fish with a white eye and a smooth modern look, set in the site header against a clean background CarpForum.co.uk wordmark in a bold flowing script style, reading CarpForum.co.uk, displayed in the site header
Menu
Utils
Go Premium Who's Online Members Weather Photo Gallery Articles
Account
Login Register
The Great Floater Debate (15 posts / 4,587 views)
AideyKaye
Posts: 1,010
Post #1 28 Apr 2023 08:03
0
So, what do we prefer?

Strike when the bait disappears, or wait for the float to start moving off?

Light inconspicuous old skool Drennans, or heavy inline floats for hooking? (if distance wasn't a factor)

Does anyone still use the Gardner suspender float to good effect?

Does anyone use braided mainline?

Does hook size really matter?

Any tips or tricks?
Goose Goose
Posts: 12,901
Post #2 28 Apr 2023 08:46
0
In reply to Post #1
Rarely use a float, freeline or fly fish.
kells kells
Posts: 6,017
Post #3 28 Apr 2023 09:50
0
In reply to Post #1
Candle for me.... it used to be back in the day anyway. Great controls didn't mind losing them ether. Great for close in work..

At distance it used to be the old anchored crust fished paternoster style with tight lines and wait for the old spool to spin. Great way to fish. You had to get it right as they were a bugger for tangles and getting the crust to pop up.

These days I use a fox bubble float though I do have a couple Drennan controllers but prefer me inline bubble float. As for when to strike I'm far to inpatient to wait for the float to move as soon as that fish mouths the hook bait the rod is behind my ear. Some you win some you lose. Floater fishing is angling in its purest form you against the fish one on one, love it.

As for hook size always to match the size of the bait your fishing with. Line nylon all the way.

Can you still buy them Gardner suspender floats. They always looked a bit cumbersome to me along with that beach caster rig..

Tips and tricks.. yes, try fishing a water with no bird life...
Tinhead Tinhead
Posts: 17,089
Post #4 28 Apr 2023 09:58
0
In reply to Post #1
My eyesight is not good enough to watch the bait.
Is the Gardner suspender the black polyball and the black stem? If so I have one of those but never got around to using it, were they any good?
NickGordon NickGordon
Posts: 3,121
Post #5 28 Apr 2023 14:31
1
In reply to Post #1
Freeline if it's close enough, a controller if not, I actually like the Nash Bolt machine, but as a Nash tackle hater I'm not allowed to say that...

Most of the time I wait until the fish turns and takes line, no need to strike but occasionally there are times when you have to strike as soon as they extend their lip over the bait.

My usual hook size is a size 10 Super Specialist, but I do also use Korda Longshanks, and Solar 101's.

As for bait, Bakers Complete Dog food, the big squares are hookbaits, the others are freebies, or whatever dry dog food Sky is on if they float.
Defiant.one Defiant.one
Posts: 4,344
Post #6 28 Apr 2023 17:10
0
In reply to Post #2
Snap extremely intensive fishing going for them on the Fly, I enjoyed it so much last year I've just treated myself to a purpose built #10 Fly Rod.
AideyKaye
Posts: 1,010
Post #7 28 Apr 2023 18:10
0
In reply to Post #5
I use the bakers too, but usually a couple within a mesh bag of mixers, with a trimmed down pop up as hookbait I think they sit lower in the water compared to a mixer and the pop-up, so it keeps them guessing.
vossy1 vossy1
MODERATORMOD
Posts: 9,046
Post #8 30 Apr 2023 08:39
0
Tesco mixed dog biscuits for me, pick out the Chum type ones for hookers, top with a bit of DNA PB stick if having trouble seeing it.
Controller, enough to get the distance req but not used for hooking unless at range.
Always site strike, don't wait for the line or float to move normally. Just don't see the need to give the fish any time to eject the bait.
Thinking of trying some of those inline Bombardia egg type with tails/inline floats. Always used ESP or Fox but changed to the Fox zig line for hook link a few years ago and find it more prone to tangles using standard floats....we'll see.
essesxandy essesxandy
Posts: 3,197
Post #9 1 May 2023 07:15
0
Has anyone else found the old ESP controllers to be less buoyant than before? I used to put an anti tangle sleeve through the eye with a swivel jammed in, but the last few I've bought won't handle it.
pearbo pearbo
Posts: 1,530
Post #10 1 May 2023 13:46
1
Given the choice I'd rather fish beach caster style, ducks leave it alone then
Belch Belch
MODERATORMOD
Posts: 4,660
Post #11 2 May 2023 09:52
0
In reply to Post #10
Beachcaster all day long . . .

1 - You can fish multiple rods
2 - Birdlife leave your hookbaits and freebies alone
3 - Carp cannot brush the line leading to the controller / hooklink to hookbait and spook
4 - If you fish a hair you can 'dapple' the hookbait with the hook itself being suspended above the water line
5 - You can be selective about what fish takes your bait by simply turning the spool and lifting it from the water without making a massive disturbance

Saying that I do like to fish a traditional controller on waters that haven't been raped on the top - braided mainline wherever allowed and a soft rod
Mistral999
Posts: 157
Post #12 2 May 2023 15:56
0
In reply to Post #11
Do you mind explaining how you set this up? Thanks
Belch Belch
MODERATORMOD
Posts: 4,660
Post #13 2 May 2023 19:24
0
In reply to Post #12
Sent you a PM so as not to bore everyone else - you owe me a £tenner!
MiniWelsh MiniWelsh
Posts: 2,383
Post #14 9 May 2023 11:50
1
In reply to Post #9
I've noticed this. This is possibly the only ESP product that I have bought and thought was crap. Not fit for purpose as it does tend to sink with the addition of any weight at all.
Leeroyjenkins Leeroyjenkins
Posts: 3,955
Post #15 9 May 2023 12:21
0
I've been using the fox bubble float which works great. I generally have found its best to just leave it untill the float moves. If I strike when I see the bait taken my conversion rate has been awful, this has been fishing for smaller carp though 8lb ish, which can be a bit skitty.

I've noticed carp going for the bubble float far more often than the hookbaits though, I'm on the look out for some small clear plastic balls to try use as a hookbait.
Are you sure?

This action cannot be undone.

Yes, continue

Loading…