CarpForum.co.uk brand mark, a blue stylized fish with a white eye and a smooth modern look, set in the site header against a clean background CarpForum.co.uk wordmark in a bold flowing script style, reading CarpForum.co.uk, displayed in the site header
Menu
Utils
Go Premium Who's Online Members Weather Venues Photo Gallery Articles Events calendar
Account
Login Register
Variation on the solid bag (11 posts / 654 views)
carpchef carpchef
Posts: 436
Post #1 11 Nov 2026 12:14
2
It is coming into solid bag time soon…I changed my bag set up slightly last year so that I can have a number of bags all ready to go but still leave the choice of hook-bait until the last minute. Pics are fairly self-explanatory.
The quick-change swivel is covered with a short section of shrink tube that the lead sits over…it is loose enough to be free running (intentional). Also, I will make a series of holes opposite where the lead is situated so it will always melt from here and the lead will be hidden underneath the pile of bait. I quite often inject some liquid just before casting. Hook bait is invariably a small wafter, colour and flavour will change depending on my mood, or a chunk of peperami or maybe a single tiger nut.








My next progression is to use this set up but with a multi rig instead of a hair…thinking about a suitable bait screw or perhaps a longish length of bait floss (knotted) that I can mount the bait on, trim and blob last minute…I need to experiment still with this development; best hook link material etc. I am happy enough with the hair version but am always looking to improve/hone things….or maybe I am just thinking too much🤔
brooksie1986 brooksie1986
Posts: 239
Post #2 11 Nov 2026 20:18
1
In reply to Post #1
Very clever and neat idea 👍
Baitman Baitman
Posts: 5,320
Post #3 11 Nov 2026 21:35
1
In reply to Post #1
Quote: I will make a series of holes opposite where the lead is situated so it will always melt from here and the lead will be hidden underneath the pile of bait.

Similar, but with more waffle 🤓
I put the lead on one side of the bag and after half filling i add the hookbait on the opposite side. I then add a couple of small holes with the tip of the scissors near the top on the opposite side once the bag is filled and tied off.
The bag is then slightly heavier on one side so will go down on the lead side, and the air can slowly escape from the other side as it sinks so making the opposite side to the lead more bouyant.
This will ensure the lead is under the pile of bait, and the hookbait isnt buried.
carpchef carpchef
Posts: 436
Post #4 12 Nov 2026 15:55
0
In reply to Post #2
Quote: Very clever and neat idea

Thank you for commenting👍👍
carpchef carpchef
Posts: 436
Post #5 12 Nov 2026 16:05
0
In reply to Post #3
Quote: I put the lead on one side of the bag and after half filling i add the hookbait on the opposite side. I then add a couple of small holes with the tip of the scissors near the top on the opposite side once the bag is filled and tied off.

I think we are both doing something similar...I take time to position the lead to one side so I can see it through the bag, I then know it will always come to rest on the lake bed with the lead at the bottom. I actually have a small bradawl that is ideal to make some holes opposite..to ensure it opens here first...as it melts the contents spread out a bit but the hook bait always remains visible....it may not be sitting on top of the pile as your method probably does, but clearly visible is good enough for me😎
carpchef carpchef
Posts: 436
Post #6 12 Nov 2026 16:28
0
In reply to Post #5
I think it is an important point to mention, when fishing a solid bag;
Careful positioning of the lead in the bag so you know how it will land, and positioning of hook bait, so you know where it will sit. To encourage the bag to melt from a certain bit of the bag by making a series of small holes/perforations with a suitable implement…it drastically affects how it melts and, ultimately, presents once fully melted.
See my hole making implements

DenzelLN
Posts: 390
Post #7 12 Nov 2026 19:14
0
In reply to Post #1
What is the benefit over a typical solid bag setup?
carpchef carpchef
Posts: 436
Post #8 12 Nov 2026 19:35
0
In reply to Post #7
Quote: What is the benefit over a typical solid bag setup?

Benefit is you can have a load of bags tied up but then decide last minute what hook bait you want to use....normal bags have the hook bait already inside the bag....maybe not that important but I like to have that last minute choice whilst still having bags pretty much ready to attach, loop to loop and cast out.😎
RKB
Posts: 1,796
Post #9 13 Nov 2026 07:22
1
I use solid bags year round but am not a fan of pre-tied bags myself. They’re quick to do, and if you’re that fussed about the hookbait, then why not the content of the bag? That white mix looks attractive to birds, so maybe some dark bait is better? Then you have the risk of it not melting because something leaked from the bait and it got into the PVA. Given they’re done in about 90 seconds, and there is a fish on the bank about once every 90 days, I just don’t see the point! I have all my solid bag gear in the car and then take what I want from that depending on venue/situation, etc. I wouldn’t want anything outside the bag (e.g the hookbait) wobbling it around in-flight more than it already does when you hoof one out! 😂
carpchef carpchef
Posts: 436
Post #10 13 Nov 2026 17:14
0
In reply to Post #9
Quote: I use solid bags year round but am not a fan of pre-tied bags myself. They’re quick to do, and if you’re that fussed about the hookbait, then why not the content of the bag? That white mix looks attractive to birds, so maybe some dark bait is better? Then you have the risk of it not melting because something leaked from the bait and it got into the PVA. Given they’re done in about 90 seconds, and there is a fish on the bank about once every 90 days, I just don’t see the point! I have all my solid bag gear in the car and then take what I want from that depending on venue/situation, etc. I wouldn’t want anything outside the bag (e.g the hookbait) wobbling it around in-flight more than it already does when you hoof one out!



Lots of really valid points here….and I agree with most of ‘em.👍
My thing with solid bags though, is that I really only use them on runs waters and I kind of feel, for efficiency’s sake, it is handy to always have some ready to go, throughout a session. I also do a lot of day sessions with first-light starts…convince me it is not a good idea to have at least a bag for each rod that you did up the night before, that only needs a hook-bait attaching…... and then “hoofing out”!!!
I am with you on not keeping bags for a long time though…I am dead against it and, like you, am worried about dissolve times being adversely affected in some way. So, I only have an ongoing supply of bags to see me through a session and try to time it that towards the end of the trip I do not have any left, just for that reason….I’d not be overly confident with left over bags on my next trip, whenever that was.
Content of the bag is just a mix that I am happy with…I do not encounter bird problems on the waters I fish but would happily change to something less visual like crushed hemp or a dark pellet, but at the moment I see a lighter mix as an advantage, I like it to stand out and be visual to the fish…the more so the better in the winter.
I do not use solid bags on harder waters, opting for a boilie only approach most of the time. I am paranoid that my bag mix is going to be scoffed by nuisance fish and I will be left with a single and nowt else. Bags I regularly recast, for this reason, and the more challenging waters I want to set my traps and leave them undisturbed until something happens.
Oh, and if I am going to fish at anything over about 40 or 50 yards, I’ll have the bait IN the bag and probably ensure the lead is at the bottom..front when cast…and the hook bait certainly not wobbling about outside, if I am trying to achieve distance and accuracy.
Intrinsically I feel we are on the same page, in a lot of ways. 😎

Belch Belch
MODERATORMOD
Posts: 4,745
Post #11 22 Nov 2026 16:05
0
Sean Harrison did something similar in the late 90s/00s . . .with the addition of using a lead clip to attach the bag. Bags pre-made / filled with primarily powders / liquid and a lead 'only' (no hook-link / hook & bait) but with the lead swivel exposed at the top to attach to a leadclip. Hook-link with bait of choice then attached to the clip swivel with a looped connection (you could use QC swivel instead these days) and the braided hook-link laid across the outer of the bag . . a long latch gate needle is pushed through the length of the bag to grab the hook-link at the exit end and the hook-link material 'pulled' back into the body until only the hair / bait is exposed (like your set up) . . .dependent on length sometimes this left a loop outside the bag in the upper part however this didn't matter as when melted would lay coiled within the bag filling . .


Best of both worlds in terms of clip attachment convenience / hook-bait flex and hook-length flex (you could go really short or use a much longer 'coiled' length) . . .Only down side is casting aerodynamics and the added weight on the clip itself - great for short to medium range - not for smashing to the horizon . . .
Are you sure?

This action cannot be undone.

Yes, continue

Loading…