CarpForum.co.uk brand mark, a blue stylized fish with a white eye and a smooth modern look, set in the site header against a clean background CarpForum.co.uk wordmark in a bold flowing script style, reading CarpForum.co.uk, displayed in the site header
Menu
Utils
Go Premium Who's Online Members Weather Venues Photo Gallery Articles Events calendar
Account
Login Register
jmorrisuk Last active 2327 days ago
Profile picture
Activity
Posts
4
Registered
22 Jun 2020 16:27
Last posted
1 Jul 2020 17:34
Contact details
Name
j******* M*****
Location
Essex
Last posts from this user
Forum / Thread
Post
Date/Time
1 Jul 2020
@ 5:34pm
Hi everyone,

This one isn't for me but a friend who doesn't do anything like this online.

They are after a new reel and are torn between a shimano Ultegra 5500 (£135) or a Wychwood big riot (£65) or Daiwa Windcast QDA Reel (£100)

What reel would you guys recommend, there is a big price difference between them and from what I've seen when I've had a quick look the Wychwood seems to have an issue with line lay which is why i avoided them recently.

cheers once again
23 Jun 2020
@ 8:56pm
In reply to Post #1
Just been offered 2 x Daiwa Crosscast BR 5000 for £45 new each and can pick up either 2 soniks for £140 or 3 Advantas for £100 what are your thoughts?

cheers
23 Jun 2020
@ 6:33pm
In reply to Post #6
Cant get the TFG's for love nor money, and annoyingly the Tribals have just sold out of the 2.75Lb TC, so was chatting to someone else about this and he also mentioned the Soniks mainly the Dominator X's saying they are excellent.
22 Jun 2020
@ 4:50pm
Hi everyone,

Ive been fishing for years on old tackle and now that the rods and reels have finally given up the ghost I'm looking to get 2 new rods and 2 new reels. The lakes i fish aren't huge (70m across) and largest Carp would be around 30lbs max from what I've been told.

i unfortunately don't have a huge budget looking around £400 for everything.

The rods I've been looking at are Tribal TX-2s 12ft 2.75 or Advanta Discovery CSX V2 Carp Rods, Length: 12ft, Test Curve: 3lb, Butt: 50mm all the reviews are pretty much the same it feels and the Advent are a fraction of the cost but I'm not 100% sure about their long term quality.

Then for reels either a Shimano Ultegra XTD Reel, Size: 5500 i know this isn't a baitrunner which i normally fish with but the reviews I've seen of this reel seem pretty impressive so I'm considering moving over to this style of reel, or i go for a shamano bait runner (no idea which one as there seems to be about 10 different types) or a Daiwa Emcast BR but people have said recently the quality of the Daiwa stuff has dropped recently.

So basically I'm completely confused and need some advice. When people say you can never have too much info they have obviously never sat looking at google for hours at different rod and reel combos with the slightest letter changing in the name changing the reel entirely

Thanks for any help in advance

Forgot to say I'm not set on those options so if you feel there is a better fit I'm all ears.

James
Are you sure?

This action cannot be undone.

Yes, continue

Loading…