Just joined the forum with the intension of outlining another solid bag variation. I’m hoping that I can find someone who is using a similar variation to compare their results. In general my syndicate lake is very weedy so I tend to use drop off leads, I have to use a tail rubber to facilitate the drop off. When in line leads are used I have no rubber protruding from the lead, I do not use a line aligner on either set up & I never pierce the bag. My hook lengths are generally 4 to 5 inches long tied with braid to size 4/5/or 6 semi barbed mugga hooks. Only a looped braid protrudes from the bag, & I tie the bag off with dissolving ties or tape. The bags I use are 55x100mm. I drop 2 x 12mm boilies into the bag bottom, which are covered & separated by roughly 1cm of 4mm pellets, this is where I want most of the air not squeezed out of the bag to collect, & no matter how tight the bag is tied off there is always air left in the bag. I cover the 4mm pellets with 1 cm of 2mm pellets, & then I lay my hook & D rigged 12mm boilie flat on top of these. I now cover the hook & hook bait with 2mm pellets holding the lead at the top of the bag without disturbing the hook’s position. I now curl the braid as I lower the 2oz lead into the bag & surround it with 2mm pellets before tying the bag off. The lead is now as close to the top of the bag as I can get it, which is exactly what I intended. When I cast out the leads weight ensures the top end of the bag hits the bottom first & in a silty bottom may even bury it self slightly, again this is what I want, because the air will rise up through the upside down bag stretching it as it does. The bag then separates in the middle & rises depositing first a layer of 2mm pellets then your hook and bait which in turn is covered by a mixture of 2 &4 mm pellets topped off with a couple of 12mm boilies. For me it has been a perfect presentation game changer. As I don’t use any liquids or oils I have no concern about when I make my bags up, in fact I’ve caught carp on bags made up weeks before I used them, although they were stored in air tight containers. The pellets do dry the boilies out, but the stored attractant is still in the bag to be released when cast out, & the carp are still feeding on them? I joined the forum for some informed comments, & perhaps some improvement on the above.
Sounds quite similar to how I set them up, although I use the Fox system to put the bags together. The only comment I have is that if your bag has air in it, not sure how far it’s gonna be burying itself in silt.
In reply to Post #2
Every bag has air in it no matter how firm you tie it, what makes the difference is size of the pellets or boilies you infill. That’s why my 12mm boilies & 4mm pellets are placed in the bottom of the bag. The lead pins the top of the bag to the lake bed ensuring perfect line lay & the air lifts the bag into a vertical position ensuring perfect presentation when the bag melts. The bag always melts in the middle because the lead at one end & the air rising makes this the weak spot. I don’t mind if the lead sinks into the silt or sits on top, it makes no difference to my presentation. I have tested this set up in an old large loft water tank over the last year to get it just so.
Every bag has air in it no matter how firm you tie it, what makes the difference is size of the pellets or boilies you infill. That’s why my 12mm boilies & 4mm pellets are placed in the bottom of the bag. The lead pins the top of the bag to the lake bed ensuring perfect line lay & the air lifts the bag into a vertical position ensuring perfect presentation when the bag melts. The bag always melts in the middle because the lead at one end & the air rising makes this the weak spot. I don’t mind if the lead sinks into the silt or sits on top, it makes no difference to my presentation. I have tested this set up in an old large loft water tank over the last year to get it just so.
When I say "if the bag has air in it", I mean, if you haven't punched it full of holes, like I do. I want my bags to get to the bottom as quickly as possible, usually to assist with feeling for a drop of some sort - I find with fewer holes, far less feeling on the drop and as such I conclude that it is not hitting the bottom as fast / hard as one with loads of holes (and in theory less air) in it. I am sure your version lands as you describe.
In the end where the 12mm boilies are could you not add a pva nugget or two? I think it would be better than trying to trap air in 🤷
First of all, thank you for engaging in the discussion. If getting a drop when using solid bags was important to me I might agree with you, but it’s not. If it were I might try using a heavier lead. The versatility of solid bags is what attracted me to them in the first place, I don’t mind not knowing what I’m fishing over, how deep it is or even how many wraps out it is. All I need to know is that I’m casting to showing fish or signs of fish. My one & only concern is being on the fish, a slight exaggeration but essentially true. Solid bags allow me this luxury, and the set up I’ve highlighted virtually guarantees my rig is presented. I know of no other technique that affords me this privilege, It’s not foolproof but what method is?
In reply to Post #5
I’m not too sure what benefit PVA nuggets would be, when the air already trapped in the bag does what’s required & is free.
I’m not too sure what benefit PVA nuggets would be, when the air already trapped in the bag does what’s required & is free.
Thats a loooong paragraph to digest . . .phew!
I use bags with drop-off inline leads and prefer the old fox impact style leads (West Country Leads do them - 'Gravity' Drop Off inlines for 60p ea!) as the hooklink exits the centre of the lead almost like a cog set up but without the agg . . . also like RKB, use the Fox Drop off inline stem system - saves faffing with tail rubbers and is consistent / foolproof / low profile.
Whatever you do with bags I always load them like the Korda Rob Burgess method . . ie with the flat face of the lead centred and to 'one side' of the bag and a single puncture hole on the opposite side with the hookbait. When packed out properly you can clearly see the face of the lead on one side, and I always do a little 'roll test' to ensure they land lead side down, every time (a bit like a method feeder would do). The worst thing IMO is bags landing / settling at a weird angle - this way its always lead down / hookbait up and dissolves more easily / less violently. . . .
Only other thing I do with bags is negate twisting and sticking / PVA tape / string to tighten the bag at the open end . . .I always fill bags about 3/4 full, then cut a central, vertical 'slot' at the top being careful to avoid the mini leader / stem as required. This way you are left with two 'bunnies ears' from the bag itself and you can simply tie two overhand knots with each 'ear' around the mini leader and get the bag really tight before snipping off any excess . . .
I use bags with drop-off inline leads and prefer the old fox impact style leads (West Country Leads do them - 'Gravity' Drop Off inlines for 60p ea!) as the hooklink exits the centre of the lead almost like a cog set up but without the agg . . . also like RKB, use the Fox Drop off inline stem system - saves faffing with tail rubbers and is consistent / foolproof / low profile.
Whatever you do with bags I always load them like the Korda Rob Burgess method . . ie with the flat face of the lead centred and to 'one side' of the bag and a single puncture hole on the opposite side with the hookbait. When packed out properly you can clearly see the face of the lead on one side, and I always do a little 'roll test' to ensure they land lead side down, every time (a bit like a method feeder would do). The worst thing IMO is bags landing / settling at a weird angle - this way its always lead down / hookbait up and dissolves more easily / less violently. . . .
Only other thing I do with bags is negate twisting and sticking / PVA tape / string to tighten the bag at the open end . . .I always fill bags about 3/4 full, then cut a central, vertical 'slot' at the top being careful to avoid the mini leader / stem as required. This way you are left with two 'bunnies ears' from the bag itself and you can simply tie two overhand knots with each 'ear' around the mini leader and get the bag really tight before snipping off any excess . . .
In reply to Post #8
Where to start? Perhaps with RKB who all ready commented that bags not punctured sink more slowly because the trapped air cannot escape, giving little indication of the drop. I agree with him. This would also indicate that there is no violent landing, which for me is a massive benefit. As for your solid bag dissolving more easily, and if I understand your horizontal set up correctly, one third of your bags surface area is face down in the silt. Whereas the system I described has considerably more surface area directly exposed to water due to the trapped air holding the bag vertical. This is the reason I use slow melt bags, the rising air acts in conjunction with the lead to stretch the bag & therefore it dissolves more easily. When the upper part of the solid bag separates from the lower half, its contents drop almost as one to cover what has stayed in situ, & what remains of the upper half of the separated bag floats away on the trapped air.
As for solid bags landing at a weird angle, once again it is vertical verses horizontal. The more area the bag covers the more chance it has of landing at a weird angle. With the system I described the bag can very rarely, if ever, lay awkwardly as the trapped air holds it in the vertical position until the bag dissolves.
As for tying off, this was for me one of the downsides of solid bags. However I tied the knot in tests it was always the last vestige to dissolve, if in deed it did dissolve. Once again the method I describe does away with this problem as the lead makes sure it is buried beneath it, so whatever method I use to tie the bag off it is never a concern.
I agree totally with tieing the bags off as tight as possible, there will always be enough air for the required outcome. More importantly it will be where it’s needed most, due to the use of larger particle at the opposite end of the lead.
I had no knowledge of the branded methods advocated, so I looked them up on line , interesting especially as you thought tail rubbers were too much faffing. You may well be correct when you describe the advertised system as consistent & low profile, but foolproof?
Where to start? Perhaps with RKB who all ready commented that bags not punctured sink more slowly because the trapped air cannot escape, giving little indication of the drop. I agree with him. This would also indicate that there is no violent landing, which for me is a massive benefit. As for your solid bag dissolving more easily, and if I understand your horizontal set up correctly, one third of your bags surface area is face down in the silt. Whereas the system I described has considerably more surface area directly exposed to water due to the trapped air holding the bag vertical. This is the reason I use slow melt bags, the rising air acts in conjunction with the lead to stretch the bag & therefore it dissolves more easily. When the upper part of the solid bag separates from the lower half, its contents drop almost as one to cover what has stayed in situ, & what remains of the upper half of the separated bag floats away on the trapped air.
As for solid bags landing at a weird angle, once again it is vertical verses horizontal. The more area the bag covers the more chance it has of landing at a weird angle. With the system I described the bag can very rarely, if ever, lay awkwardly as the trapped air holds it in the vertical position until the bag dissolves.
As for tying off, this was for me one of the downsides of solid bags. However I tied the knot in tests it was always the last vestige to dissolve, if in deed it did dissolve. Once again the method I describe does away with this problem as the lead makes sure it is buried beneath it, so whatever method I use to tie the bag off it is never a concern.
I agree totally with tieing the bags off as tight as possible, there will always be enough air for the required outcome. More importantly it will be where it’s needed most, due to the use of larger particle at the opposite end of the lead.
I had no knowledge of the branded methods advocated, so I looked them up on line , interesting especially as you thought tail rubbers were too much faffing. You may well be correct when you describe the advertised system as consistent & low profile, but foolproof?
Not all bags 'dissolve' equally . . .this does depend on how they are loaded, however most unpunctured bags can 'explode' at their weakest point, which can affect the final presentation. I think your taking a risk and assuming a slower air assisted drop is an advantage . . check out the plethora of online vids to prove this. Whilst a 'parachute' set up can be a benefit on heavily silted spots, a properly weighted bag (with the lead on one side) ensures the bag always lands weight down and hookbait up (irrespective of whether its landing in silt or on gravel) - which helps me sleep at night. A single puncture close to the hookbait (positioned on the opposite side to the lead and not in a corner below) also ALWAYS puts the hookbait in prime position . . .as well as ensuring the bag 'explodes' evenly and negates the chance of significant residue around the hookbait once the bag has settled . . .
Leads are of course your choice - I just think the Gravity version has a better location for the swivel as it exits at the centre - they also work perfectly with the Fox inline kit. Re the kit itself - I fished a water for many years that demands all leads above 1.5oz are dropped - the Fox kit has never let me down with the stem negating any doubt that a tail rubber pushed on a fraction too hard can create. Another benefit to these kits however is that you CAN add a tail rubber if you want to slow/hinder the drop off process . . .although personally, I think retaining a heavy inline lead on a 3inch braided hooklink thats knocking about on the fishes face/eye when your playing it is not really ideal . . .its all about percentages - each to their own!
Leads are of course your choice - I just think the Gravity version has a better location for the swivel as it exits at the centre - they also work perfectly with the Fox inline kit. Re the kit itself - I fished a water for many years that demands all leads above 1.5oz are dropped - the Fox kit has never let me down with the stem negating any doubt that a tail rubber pushed on a fraction too hard can create. Another benefit to these kits however is that you CAN add a tail rubber if you want to slow/hinder the drop off process . . .although personally, I think retaining a heavy inline lead on a 3inch braided hooklink thats knocking about on the fishes face/eye when your playing it is not really ideal . . .its all about percentages - each to their own!
In reply to Post #10
I totally agree that the weakest point of a solid bag is almost certainly where the breakthrough into its contents start, which is why I ensure that I’m almost certain I know where this action is going to take place. With air pressure rising into the upper layers of the solid bag & the lead ensuring the lower layers are anchored to the bottom, the weakest spot will be where the bag is stretched most, the middle. It’s not an exact science I will admit, but it’s about as close as I can get. What’s more in the tests I carried out once the break occurs it runs the entire circumference of the vertical bag almost instantaneously. Every problem starts at the weakest point in any given action, & this is no less true for solid bags whether punctured or not. I do agree that not all bags dissolve equally, but by using what I consider to be the best on the market I can induce that weak spot to be where I want it to be in my solid bags.
I do understand that when using the word explode you are trying describe the release of the bags contents, but having watched this release the spread is minimal & no more than I find acceptable.
I must admit I’m struggling to find a negative in an air assisted drop, when all said & done I’m assuming most carp fisherman who cast at showing fish feather the drop! Why not then have an air feathered drop through the water columns?
Every time I have dropped this set up into a test tank, the lead end of the bag hits the deck first, & I see no reason to assume it would be different in a lake.
You did make me smile at your taking a risk comment, when you consider the multitude of other things we assume have fallen into place every time we cast out. And why would the system I’ve outlined be more effective on heavily silted spots, as opposed to lightly silted, weedy, or gravel spots? I can assure you that this presentation would be just as good on any of them.
As for giving myself sleepless nights, it doesn’t happen, but then again I don’t fish nights. I smiled again at your plethora of under water videos quip, I did actually watch one once, it was longer than a big budget movie & I make no further comment.
Like most of the equipment I use it’s for practicality, my leads tend to be as small as possible in the 2oz range & are made by one of the less well known brands. This allows me to get a slightly larger quantity of pellet inside the size of bag I prefer to use. Having devised a method of losing the lead but not the lead stem & using loop to loop knots, most rig changes I make can be completed in minutes. It has also been notable this season that not once have I reeled in a fish with the drop off lead still attached.
I totally agree that the weakest point of a solid bag is almost certainly where the breakthrough into its contents start, which is why I ensure that I’m almost certain I know where this action is going to take place. With air pressure rising into the upper layers of the solid bag & the lead ensuring the lower layers are anchored to the bottom, the weakest spot will be where the bag is stretched most, the middle. It’s not an exact science I will admit, but it’s about as close as I can get. What’s more in the tests I carried out once the break occurs it runs the entire circumference of the vertical bag almost instantaneously. Every problem starts at the weakest point in any given action, & this is no less true for solid bags whether punctured or not. I do agree that not all bags dissolve equally, but by using what I consider to be the best on the market I can induce that weak spot to be where I want it to be in my solid bags.
I do understand that when using the word explode you are trying describe the release of the bags contents, but having watched this release the spread is minimal & no more than I find acceptable.
I must admit I’m struggling to find a negative in an air assisted drop, when all said & done I’m assuming most carp fisherman who cast at showing fish feather the drop! Why not then have an air feathered drop through the water columns?
Every time I have dropped this set up into a test tank, the lead end of the bag hits the deck first, & I see no reason to assume it would be different in a lake.
You did make me smile at your taking a risk comment, when you consider the multitude of other things we assume have fallen into place every time we cast out. And why would the system I’ve outlined be more effective on heavily silted spots, as opposed to lightly silted, weedy, or gravel spots? I can assure you that this presentation would be just as good on any of them.
As for giving myself sleepless nights, it doesn’t happen, but then again I don’t fish nights. I smiled again at your plethora of under water videos quip, I did actually watch one once, it was longer than a big budget movie & I make no further comment.
Like most of the equipment I use it’s for practicality, my leads tend to be as small as possible in the 2oz range & are made by one of the less well known brands. This allows me to get a slightly larger quantity of pellet inside the size of bag I prefer to use. Having devised a method of losing the lead but not the lead stem & using loop to loop knots, most rig changes I make can be completed in minutes. It has also been notable this season that not once have I reeled in a fish with the drop off lead still attached.