I am currently looking at moving way from a traditional barrow bag and moving to a more compact rucksack. I have been looking at the Korda 30l Dark Camo and the Thinking Anglers Rucksack. To be honest I am struggling to decide, any user feedback for either would be much appreciated.
In reply to Post #1
I've got the Thinking Anglers one and I really like it. It's small which made me cut down on my gear. Others have struggled with where it sits on your back but I've not had a problem. Not used the Korda one but I reckon either will be good mate.
I've got the Thinking Anglers one and I really like it. It's small which made me cut down on my gear. Others have struggled with where it sits on your back but I've not had a problem. Not used the Korda one but I reckon either will be good mate.
I have the thinking anglers rucksack and find it uncomfortable. doesn't sit nicely on the back. going back to my nash
In reply to Post #1
Have both. Both are great tbh you get a little more room in the TA one though with the additional pocket on top and you can add the little extra side pouches too if needed. Id go for the TA one out of the two
Have both. Both are great tbh you get a little more room in the TA one though with the additional pocket on top and you can add the little extra side pouches too if needed. Id go for the TA one out of the two
In reply to Post #3
I also found the TA sack uncomfortable for long walks. To be fair it is well made and designed, but after a few minutes it becomes uncomfortable.
I also found the TA sack uncomfortable for long walks. To be fair it is well made and designed, but after a few minutes it becomes uncomfortable.
In reply to Post #5
Some great feedback! When you say uncomfortable, are we talking painful or awkward? Like strap can't in or just doesn't sit right?
Some great feedback! When you say uncomfortable, are we talking painful or awkward? Like strap can't in or just doesn't sit right?
In reply to Post #1
I've just done a similar switch but with Trakker Scout rucksack. 2 trips done so far and initial view is the rucksack is great, but that shape isn't the most comfortable to actually carry. It sits so high on your back and straps short. I'd imagine the ones you're looking at are similar.
I wonder if a slightly larger one might actually be more comfortable? I'm going to try and find a shop where I can put a couple on to try.
I've just done a similar switch but with Trakker Scout rucksack. 2 trips done so far and initial view is the rucksack is great, but that shape isn't the most comfortable to actually carry. It sits so high on your back and straps short. I'd imagine the ones you're looking at are similar.
I wonder if a slightly larger one might actually be more comfortable? I'm going to try and find a shop where I can put a couple on to try.
In reply to Post #6
I've had 2 mk 1 mk2 and camo ta rucksacks they are uncomfortable the side straps dig in and the sternum strap is to high can end up at your throat I've spoke to ta years ago that the harness needs redesigned I now have the Korda 30lt it's a bit more comfortable but I was disappointed in the cut backs Korda have made no padding on pockets and no sternum strap
The zips are good and the design is ok tbh what you need is a mixture of both
If you want a comfortable rucksack the drennan specialist takes some beating
I've had 2 mk 1 mk2 and camo ta rucksacks they are uncomfortable the side straps dig in and the sternum strap is to high can end up at your throat I've spoke to ta years ago that the harness needs redesigned I now have the Korda 30lt it's a bit more comfortable but I was disappointed in the cut backs Korda have made no padding on pockets and no sternum strap
The zips are good and the design is ok tbh what you need is a mixture of both
If you want a comfortable rucksack the drennan specialist takes some beating
I have the ESP rucksack, lovely but a little small and does not sit well on my back - I am 6ft 6 though.
Looked at the TA one, nice design, bag not for me though.
Tried the carp life one and everything very well laid out and bag sits very comfortably. It is not as small as the TA one though.
Looked at the TA one, nice design, bag not for me though.
Tried the carp life one and everything very well laid out and bag sits very comfortably. It is not as small as the TA one though.
Carp life Eclipse gets goods reviews, although bit bigger than the Korda and TA one
In reply to Post #1
I have the Saber copy of the TA one.
I think it's great - small and comfortable.
I mostly use it for mobile river fishing. I bought a bigger ESP one but never use it.
I have the Saber copy of the TA one.
I think it's great - small and comfortable.
I mostly use it for mobile river fishing. I bought a bigger ESP one but never use it.
Always used ex British Army gear, day pack for a small bag like you need and a Bergen when carrying a big load. Being for army use they are tried and tested for long term comfort when wearing all day, so more than enough for fishing.
Bought both about 10 years ago used and will probably outlast me.
Bought both about 10 years ago used and will probably outlast me.
In reply to Post #12
I have had the TA for about 2 years, comfortable and easy length of room, only negative if the pockets in the main compartment don't seem to fit anything and are mostly redundant
I have had the TA for about 2 years, comfortable and easy length of room, only negative if the pockets in the main compartment don't seem to fit anything and are mostly redundant
In reply to Post #13
Thank you all for the response, some great points to think about.
Thank you all for the response, some great points to think about.
In reply to Post #14
Actually just found the caravan carpers review on Youtube for this stuff. Seems like loads of people have had issues (just by the comments) of the bags sucking up water and it being damp on the inside.
Actually just found the caravan carpers review on Youtube for this stuff. Seems like loads of people have had issues (just by the comments) of the bags sucking up water and it being damp on the inside.