CarpForum.co.uk brand mark, a blue stylized fish with a white eye and a smooth modern look, set in the site header against a clean background CarpForum.co.uk wordmark in a bold flowing script style, reading CarpForum.co.uk, displayed in the site header
Menu
Utils
Go Premium Who's Online Members Weather Venues Photo Gallery Articles Events calendar
Account
Login Register
Ultimate Milk Protein base mix? (212 posts / 40,644 views)
TCarper TCarper
Posts: 4,667
Post #215 13 Nov 2026 23:38
7
What I'm about to say is only my personal opinion. It's not a problem if yours is different. I will share with you my findings about milks over my lifetime of finding out what works & what does not regarding carp. I've said it before on here, but it kinda got lost in so much pointless arguing. I often hold back my opinions about stuff like this, for those exact reasons.

I would not ever be using milks inside our hook baits. It's not about cost, we use far more expensive ingredients. It's because they bring zero attraction to the table. In my findings, they are absolutely useless. You could make a milk based bait that costs the earth, all singing and all dancing. A simple fishmeal, or nut bait will out fish it by a very long way in reality. Milks are generally used these days, only in nut baits or fishmeal baits. Add ons. Only to make it sound good in reality in my opinion. They bring nothing to the table whatsoever. I think, they actually make a bait worse, not better. The fact that they cost so much now, makes that mistake if I am correct, a very expensive one indeed.

Fish will eat ANYTHING. Absolutely anything that even resembles food. That's not what we are speaking about. We are speaking about fish/carp in general, who get fished for continuously & have a choice in what type of food to pick up. Fish a milk/semo based bait next to a simple bird food/semo, a fish meal/semo, a nut meal/semo, there will always be the same outcome. The milks are by far the worst of the lot. Summer, winter, it does not matter.

There has never been a blockbuster (results) commercial milk based bait for carp. Not ever. That's for damn good reasons too, which are not about cost. The only really successful baits containing milks, are freezer baits containing loads of nut, or loads of fishmeal. You would be far better off spending your money upping the fishmeal or the nut in your freezer baits. In my opinion, they do not want the milks in those baits that do contain milks anyway. The binders are more attractive to the carp than the milks. The milks only work, by throwing loads of fish meal or nut meal with them. Use them on their own, you will not catch very much, certainly not if others around you are using fishmeal or nut baits.

One of the great fallacies in carp fishing bait in my opinion. Certainly not the only one either.

That's not to say that other fish do not find milks attractive, namely barbel for example. Although carp and barbel share a lot of the same characteristics/tastes for food, namely fishmeal & particles. Certain other things they like, tend to differ massively. Carp absolutely adore nuts. Barbel don't find nuts anywhere near as attractive as carp do. Don't know why, it's just the way that it is. I'm told by barbel anglers that I respect, that milks are a winner for the barbel. In terms of carp, I'd say the absolute complete opposite is true. Just like nuts.
silverfish silverfish
Posts: 2,694
Post #216 14 Nov 2026 07:43
0
In reply to Post #215
I can't disagree with you, nor would I attempt to make an argument for or against, shame really as discussion is the basis of a forum.
Apologies for the edit, shift working and not making that much sense

I primarily use refined milk with fishmeals 6-8%..I'd like to use more a la original Big Fish Mix recipe.,
And besides funtionality of binding and hardening it would be cheaper even at todays prices to add more hydrolyzed/enzyme treated marine powders for attraction.
.
Perhaps hanging onto a 30-40 year old fallacy or misconception by using a higher precentage of refined milks. I've made fairly decent baits with and without. Not allπŸ‘πŸ‘Ž
Companys with buying power and sources can afford to include ( or retain inclusions of) some refined milks, they may quote 'milks' in their recipes but it's almost certainly not as much as 'we' would like to think.

Personally I haven't found nut based mixes to give the same results as fish, guess that is what you end up with fishing waters that have predominant use of fishmeals.

In the vein of this thread I made up a small batch of base for 'winter bait' from what I had at hand, (the hydro whey was an unexpected gift) for fun as much as using something different to the the multitude of baits that go into the water I fish.

With all honesty, it's meant to be a soluable day session bait and wouldn't expect it to remain on the hair if wound in quickly after 24 hours
And with more enzyme activity than the water from my rain butt freebies would definitely pop up and become floating birdfood in warm water after 36 or less. Shed window tests showed that the liver powder was going to be rather active.

I missed out the albumen because I didn't want to lock it up ( was considering whole egg powder or just more semo πŸ˜€) but neither did I plan on the huge silver fish population waking up once the water temp started to drop.

I will also be having a few day sessions on a stretch of river known to contain barbel, whether the bait does any better than a big chunk of bacon grill is yet to be seen. Every possibility it will be more effective used as a paste wrap.
Might turn out to be chub food- if the silvers don't blitz it and I hope that it won't be as attractive to the pike as meat like last winter.
Are you sure?

This action cannot be undone.

Yes, continue

Loading…