I have a different take on the Shelfie v fresh debate. And that is palatability . Now I've not really used any of the more modern Shelf life , stabilised baits that are out there. But I know you will be hard pressed to tell the difference by looks alone.

But from experience the like of the old Richworth, crafty catcher preserved baits were like bullets. Yes you will catch on them. But long term no. Fish will go for the easiest meal possible and chewing through a load of marbles is not the one long term.

The reason I believe the likes of Mainlines Cell is so effective is it goes to mush after a few hours in the water. Soggy bread like consistency. Whether there's any in the baits make up, who knows. Carp love bread.

Tiger nuts great bait. But not as good as Peanuts. Lot more palatable squash between thumb and forefinger.

Maybe Palatability is a thread on its own. And not for this one. Just my thoughts.

I've been using Trent's stabilized since it came out and I've seen no difference in quality. Did away with my freezer and just have 25k a time

In reply to Post #17
The stabilised modern shelf life's break down and go soft just as fast.

Well the quality ones do.