In reply to Post #1
One of the risks you have of trying to work out a recipe on paper is that it may not roll correctly and you will not find this out until you roll it. To get rid of that risk, it would be worth using a base mix that someone else has formulated and not add any ingredients that could upset the balance. If you are looking for cheap, then just go for the 50/50 mix and add fish liquids. IMO, if you are looking for longevity, spend a bit more on a HNV Base Mix. If you really want to save money and produce a high quality bait, you will have to do a lot of research, buy ingredients in bulk and probably try a vast amount of recipes before getting it right.

I went though this process years ago and found I spent a huge amount on ingredients, rolling tables, mixer, massive saucepan, air dry bags, etc. not to mention a huge commitment in time to research and make the baits. I have several recipes that I know will roll well and catch carp, but it probably would have saved money and a lot of hassle by simply picking a proven bait manufacturer and buy bait in bulk! Pause for thought.

I never knew that. I had often wondered the same!